Major-carrier comparison

AT&T vs. T-Mobile: compare the whole family plan

Both carriers use line-count pricing and offer premium data, hotspot, device promotions and international benefits. The useful comparison is the full household cost for the features you actually use.

At a glance: AT&T currently offers Value 2.0, Extra 2.0, Premium 2.0 and Elite 2.0. T-Mobile's current core lineup includes T-Mix Standard, T-Mix More and T-Mix Loaded. Both use multi-line pricing and add taxes or fees outside the headline plan price.
Comparison pointAT&TT-Mobile
Current core plan structureValue 2.0, Extra 2.0, Premium 2.0, Elite 2.0T-Mix Standard, T-Mix More, T-Mix Loaded
Family pricingPer-line pricing decreases with qualifying multi-line accountsAccount pricing varies by number of lines and plan tier
Taxes and feesExtraExtra, including provider recovery fees and location-dependent taxes/surcharges
Premium dataVaries by tier; Premium and Elite offer unlimited high-speed data that does not slow based on usageT-Mix Standard is the entry tier; T-Mix More and T-Mix Loaded are the higher tiers
HotspotAllowance increases by tierT-Mix Loaded includes 250GB of high-speed hotspot, the lineup's highest benefit; T-Mix More's allotment is being re-verified
Premium extrasHigher tiers add international and connected-device benefitsHigher T-Mix tiers add entertainment, travel, upgrade and connected-device benefits
Checking provider-data freshness…
  • Taxes & fees: Extra; not included in the advertised plan prices

Plans we track: AT&T Value 2.0, AT&T Extra 2.0, AT&T Premium 2.0, AT&T Elite 2.0, AT&T 55+. Current standard prices load in the live table when our records have been verified within the last 7 days; otherwise use the official plans link for current pricing.

Provider

T-Mobile

View official plans
  • Taxes & fees: Extra; provider recovery fees, government taxes and other surcharges may apply

Plans we track: T-Mix Standard, T-Mix More, T-Mix Loaded. Current standard prices load in the live table when our records have been verified within the last 7 days; otherwise use the official plans link for current pricing.

Compare the total for the same number of lines

Both carriers use multi-line pricing, so a one-line advertisement is not a useful comparison for a four-line household. Compare the total recurring service cost for your actual line count, then add taxes, fees, watches, tablets and recurring extras.

Premium data and hotspot can justify a higher tier for some households

AT&T and T-Mobile both reserve larger hotspot allowances and more premium-data benefits for higher plan tiers. If a household rarely uses hotspot or heavy mobile data, paying for the top tier may not provide much practical value. Heavy users may see the comparison differently.

Entertainment and connected-device benefits are not free if you would not buy them

T-Mobile's T-Mix plans emphasize bundled entertainment and travel benefits. AT&T's higher tiers emphasize premium data, hotspot, international service and connected-device discounts. Treat a bundled benefit as savings only when it replaces something the household would otherwise pay for.

Device promotions can dominate the short-term math

Both carriers regularly advertise smartphone promotions with eligibility, financing and service requirements. Separate those temporary device incentives from the underlying service price so the long-term comparison remains clear.

Questions to answer before choosing

  • How many phone lines are on the account?
  • Which network is stronger at home, work, school and regular travel locations?
  • How much hotspot data does each line need?
  • Do you use the entertainment or international benefits included in premium tiers?
  • Are any device promotions or trade-in credits currently active?
  • What will the recurring bill be after taxes, fees and discounts?

Sources